C004 — Self-Audit¶

ROBIS 4-Domain Audit¶

Rating: Low risk

Criterion	Assessment
Criteria defined before searching	Yes — structural verification against primary source
Criteria applied consistently	Yes

Notes: Straightforward structural verification.

Rating: Low risk

Criterion	Assessment
Multiple search strategies used	N/A — primary source examination only
Searches designed to test each hypothesis	Yes — examined the full document
All results dispositioned	Yes
Source diversity achieved	N/A — single definitive source

Notes: External searches not required for structural claims about a document we have direct access to.

Rating: Low risk

Criterion	Assessment
All sources scored using same framework	Yes
Evidence typed consistently	Yes
ACH matrix applied	Yes
Diagnosticity analysis performed	Yes

Notes: Consistent evaluation.

Rating: Low risk

Criterion	Assessment
All hypotheses given fair hearing	Yes
Contradictory evidence surfaced	N/A — no contradictory evidence exists
Confidence calibrated to evidence	Yes
Gaps acknowledged	Yes

Notes: No synthesis concerns for structural verification.

Rating: Low risk

Source	Claim in Assessment	Source Actually Says	Match?
SRC01	12 rules, 4 groups, 3 each	Verified: Truth Hierarchy (1-3), Anti-Sycophancy (4-6), Evidence Handling (7-9), Process Compliance (10-12)	Yes

Discrepancies found: 0

Corrections applied: None needed

Unresolved flags: None

Notes: Exact match.

Overall risk of bias: Low risk

Simple structural verification with no ambiguity.

COI note: The researcher is the prompt author. However, structural claims about document content are objectively verifiable and not subject to interpretation bias.