Q001-H2 — No Such Complete Prompts Exist¶
Statement¶
No complete, usable AI/LLM system prompt implementing a full analytical rigor framework for research has been published. Only narrow-task prompts (abstract screening, checklist verification, single-step extraction) exist in the published literature and prompt repositories.
Status¶
Partially supported — The evidence strongly shows no complete prompts exist, but partial implementations go beyond simple narrow tasks, making the strict "only narrow-task" claim too strong.
Supporting Evidence¶
| Evidence ID | Summary | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| SRC01-E01 | Comprehensive taxonomy found no full-framework prompt | Strong |
| SRC04-E01 | Commercial system prompts lack analytical frameworks | Strong |
| SRC03-E01 | PRISMA-trAIce is a reporting checklist, not an operational prompt | Moderate |
Contradicting Evidence¶
| Evidence ID | Summary | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| SRC02-E01 | sroberts implemented 3 SATs including ACH — beyond narrow tasks | Moderate |
| SRC05-E01 | Agent Laboratory implements multi-phase research pipeline | Moderate |
| SRC06-E01 | AI-Researcher implements complete research workflow | Moderate |
Reasoning¶
The "no such prompts exist" hypothesis is too absolute. While no complete analytical rigor framework exists as a system prompt, several implementations go beyond narrow tasks: sroberts implements ACH and Key Assumptions Check; Agent Laboratory and AI-Researcher implement multi-phase research pipelines. However, these are implemented in code (Python + LangChain) rather than as deployable system prompts, and they do not implement named analytical rigor frameworks (ICD 203, GRADE, etc.).