R0031/2026-03-27/C012 — Claim Definition¶
Claim as Received¶
The AIA icon system was proposed by Avery, Abril, and del Riego with graduated visual indicators for AI involvement levels: Generated, Edited, Suggested (published in Journal of Technology, Innovation and Practice, 2024).
Claim as Clarified¶
The AIA icon system was proposed by Avery, Abril, and del Riego with graduated visual indicators for AI involvement levels: Generated, Edited, Suggested (published in Journal of Technology, Innovation and Practice, 2024).
BLUF¶
The paper exists (Avery, Abril, del Riego, 2024) and proposes an AIA badge system. However: (1) the journal is the Northwestern Journal of Technology and Intellectual Property, not 'Journal of Technology, Innovation and Practice'; (2) the badges delineate involvement 'from research to writing to editing' but the specific labels 'Generated, Edited, Suggested' could not be confirmed from abstracts. The journal name is clearly wrong.
Scope¶
- Domain: AI attribution, film studies, academic standards
- Timeframe: Various
- Testability: Verifiable against primary sources
Assessment Summary¶
Probability: Unlikely (20-45%)
Confidence: Medium
Hypothesis outcome: Hypothesis supported: H2 — Paper and concept exist but journal name is wrong and icon labels unverified. Hypotheses eliminated: H1 (journal name is definitively wrong), H3 (paper does exist).
[Full assessment in assessment.md.]
Status¶
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Date created | 2026-03-27 |
| Date completed | 2026-03-27 |
| Researcher profile | None provided |
| Prompt version | Unified Research Standard v1.0-draft |
| Revisit by | 2027-03-27 |
| Revisit trigger | New evidence or policy updates |