C001 — Self-Audit¶


Research	R0002 — Research Standards for AI-Assisted Writing
Run	2026-03-13
Claim	C001

Summary¶

Domain	Rating
Eligibility criteria	Low risk
Search comprehensiveness	Low risk
Evaluation consistency	Low risk
Synthesis fairness	Low risk

Overall risk of bias: Low

Detail¶

Eligibility Criteria¶

Rating: Low risk

Sources were included if they directly addressed ICD 203 tradecraft standards or the probability scale. The primary government source (DNI Objectivity page) was prioritized. Secondary sources were included for cross-reference and verification. No borderline decisions were required.

Search Comprehensiveness¶

Rating: Low risk

Six searches conducted: initial broad search (S01), probability scale search (S02), two failed PDF fetch attempts (S03, S04), successful HTML fetch (S05), and name verification (S06). The primary source was ultimately accessed despite two failed PDF attempts. Both confirming and disconfirming evidence was found.

Evaluation Consistency¶

Rating: Low risk

All sources evaluated using the same scorecard dimensions. The primary government source and secondary sources received consistent treatment. Label discrepancies were identified and weighted appropriately regardless of whether they confirmed or complicated the claim.

Synthesis Fairness¶

Rating: Low risk

The synthesis explicitly identifies both confirmed and inaccurate elements. The claim is not simply marked "right" or "wrong" — it is marked as structurally correct with two specific label inaccuracies. The mapping table between claim labels and official descriptions provides transparent evidence for the assessment.

Flags¶

No flags raised.